Aman New York vs The Cloister at Sea Island
Aman vs Independent — side-by-side hotel comparison
The Hotel Flock Verdict
Aman New York scores 9.3 overall; The Cloister at Sea Island scores 9.6. The Cloister at Sea Island scores higher on our rubric.
Scores & Facts
| Metric | Aman New York | The Cloister at Sea Island |
|---|---|---|
| Hotel Flock Score | 9.3 | 9.6 |
| Location | 9.5 | 9.7 |
| Service | 9.3 | 9.8 |
| Design | 9.4 | 9.7 |
| Dining | 9.0 | 9.6 |
| Value | 7.2 | 8.6 |
| Category | City | Beach |
| Tier | Ultra-Luxury | Ultra-Luxury |
| Opened | 2022 | 1928 |
| From | $2,400/night | $950/night |
| Rooms | 83 | 265 rooms and suites |
| Architect | 1921 Warren & Wetmore building, restored by Jean-Michel Gathy | Addison Mizner / Peter de Bretteville |
Dining
| Metric | Aman New York | The Cloister at Sea Island |
|---|---|---|
| Dining Venues | 2 | 2 |
Rooms
| Metric | Aman New York | The Cloister at Sea Island |
|---|---|---|
| Room Categories | 3 | 3 |
| Suite / Villa Types | 2 | 2 |
Spa
| Metric | Aman New York | The Cloister at Sea Island |
|---|---|---|
| Spa Programme | Yes | Yes |
| Spa Facilities Listed | 4 | 4 |
Good to Know
Aman New York
- The hotel's jazz club, in the building's restored 1920s vault, is open to outside guests and worth a visit even if you're not staying.
- Directly on Fifth Avenue at 57th Street — steps from Central Park, but genuinely quiet once you're inside given the building's thick 1921 construction.
- This is Aman's highest-priced US city hotel — book well ahead for any meaningful rate.
The Cloister at Sea Island
- All-inclusive ranch rates include all gourmet dining, sommelier-selected beverages, and daily guided adventures.
- Book fly-fishing guides, equestrian trail rides, and signature spa sessions prior to arrival.
- Private airport transfers from regional airfields can be coordinated directly with the concierge desk.
Summary
The Cloister at Sea Island scores higher on our rubric.